Response: Pallisades Fire and Cassandra
Jan 9, 2025
Dear Monique,
My heart is breaking for LA. We know this all too well, in Alberta, in BC.
But still, even after Slave Lake, Fort McMurray, Lytton, Jasper, we are sitting here believing that this can't happen here, it wouldn't happen here (it just happens in rural areas, in the wild)- surely the fire department would get it under control quickly- and of course they would do their level best. Fort Mac thought that too. What they learned, is that there are house fires-- structure fires-- and there are wildfires, and when wildfires start structure fires, everything we think know is wrong.
Here are some things I’ve learned from reading first hand accounts from firefighters, wildfire fighters, and other first responders following the Slave Lake (2011) and Fort McMurray(2016) and Jasper (2024) fires-- the things that make what we are watching happen in LA, a well- resourced, experienced, metropolitan centre. These are the things that haunt me. These are the things I don't want to forget.
I'm not a fire specialist. But I'm doing my best to learn what I can as a layperson. Wildfires burn differently. We all need to read up on it and learn about how these fires taught us that we actually don’t really understand fire-- in fact I urge everyone to do this. These are things that stood out to me, as I pondered, how this can happen in big cities with good fire-fighting resources and experience.
1. Wildfires burn hotter. A 2500 square foot house can be entirely consumed to ash in 5 min. To ash. Fire fighters can not contain this. This is not a typical house fire.
2. Houses that contain a lot of synthetic material will burn faster (think carpets, synthetic drapes, sofas, things made from wood composite with lots of glues, vinyl siding, laminate flooring.) "Legacy" (antique) furnishings, hardwoods burn more slowly.
3. Wildfire in urban centres can not be fought by conventional methods. The water in hydrants and hoses literally turns to steam. I keep seeing posts in social media platforms that the hydrants were dry, that this must be because the lines were cut off. I'm going to suggest that there was water in those hydrant lines, but like it did in Fort Mac, the water was vaporized by the heat of the fires.
4. Flames are taller. Hundreds of feet in some cases. This means that fire fighters can’t get hoses on top of the flames to douse them; the water turns to steam, for one, and the spray becomes too fine even if it hasn't vapourized. Nor can water bombers fly over and douse them effectively (they can’t get in close enough, fly low enough to be effective-- steam, fine spray).
5. Vehicles with gas tanks are bombs. In Fort Mac, first responders discovered on the fly that using heavy equipment to move vehicles out the fire’s path (literally bulldozing cars out of potential reach), or push them into the basements of houses (thereby collapsing the house too and removing easy fuel source), meant that they were able to lower the height of the fire, allowing firefighters a better chance of attacking the fire, and create fire breaks and prevent some vehicle explosions. (there is a harrowing account of this strategy as described by the first responders in John Vaillant's Fire Weather. I wept through that entire chapter)
6. The heat inside of a house surrounded by flames will boil water, explode windows, and the freakish high heat alone can cause combustion where there is not yet already a fire. Spontaneous combustion is real.
7. Sparks, ashes can travel long distances and start new fires. In Fort Mac the fire breached the Athabasca River a one of its widest points-- 1 km-- easy peasy. Again, in social media, I'm seeing people puzzled about how/why so many new fires have started, that it must be arson. But I'm looking at the size of the flames, and I'm looking at the high winds, and just as happened in Fort Mac, in Lytton, in Jasper I hazard to suggest that 80 mph winds can easily carry live ash more than a km.
8. Everything is combustible. But not everything is meant to be combustible. Toxic fumes are one problem, but a lack of oxygen is another. If you are in the middle of a conflagration, available oxygen will be very low-- fire is fueled by any an all available oxygen. These are environments in which people will not last long, even if they are not being burned.
9. Intense wildfires create their own weather. The heat lowers air humidity (and in California it's already low, as it is in Alberta most of the time too), and creates its own lightning-- that will start more fires, as well as tornado like activity, and winds of its own. So even if the wind is relatively low when the fire starts, the fire will cause the wind to pick up significantly. Los Angeles is experiencing unprecedented high winds in addition to what the fire itself will create.
10. Fire rips quickly up hill.
This is the information I carry in my head.
Sending Love to LA
Sources:
Sources: